Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

6

Posted by Catherine | Posted in General Animal Rights Stuff | Posted on 30-05-2010

Tags: , , , ,

free range barn1 Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

An example of a free range farm

Everyone seems to know that free range eggs are more humane than those from battery farms, but in this article I want to take a look at why continuing to eat eggs (even free range) is contributing hugely to animal misery. Although free range is an important step in the right direction, meaning one kind of horrific abuse the hens will no longer have to endure, the only way to ensure chickens do not suffer is to stop eating eggs altogether.

Let’s take a look at why vegans do not eat eggs…

Would You Grind Up Baby Chicks Alive?

If you wouldn’t then you probably shouldn’t eat eggs. Battery farms, free range farms, barn laid farms, hobby farmers they all share one thing in common – they have to get their layer hens from somewhere. They orderĀ  their layer hens from companies who breed birds especially for the purpose of becoming commercial layers. The companies that produce these birds do so by mating two different breeds together. A hen from one breed and a rooster from another. They create the layer hen (a hybrid) for maximum amount of eggs for the

male chicks2 Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

Discarded male chicks dead, dying, crushed

cheapest amount of money (food). The exact “formula” for the hybrid layer hen is a closely guarded secret by the industry.

When the chicks hatch they are sorted into males and females. Like every other part of the industry this is a clinical process and similar to the way factory workers would sort inanimate objects (eg screws and bolts). Before they are 72 hours old the chicks arrive on a conveyor belt and the females are sorted to one side and the males to the other. About half of the chicks are male.

Males are then killed, as there is no need for them in the industry. Their bodies are not suitable for meat, they are not used for breeding and they cannot lay eggs. Various farms use different methods to kill the chicks, although often the cheapest and easiest way will win.

Common Methods Include:

  1. Crushing/Suffocation – Chicks are piled into garbage bags alive, where they are either crushed as more chicks are piled on top of them, or they suffocate in the bag. Chicks will try to make their way to the top, but will not succeed. They are treated as trash whilst still alive. Whilst some chicks are still alive these bags of chicks may be spread onto fields using machinery to fertilize crops.
  2. Maceration – A high speed grinder is used. The chicks are dropped alive into the grinder.
  3. Cervical Dislocation – Breaking the chicks neck (less common)
  4. Electrocution - A new and apparently more humane method (not sure electrocution is all that humane. I’ve been shocked before and it didn’t feel good)
  5. Gassing - The chicks are gassed to death. This is probably the most humane, most expensive and least used method of killing.

Bear in mind that if you are a backyard farmer and decide to avoid the cruelty above by buying fertilized eggs, rather than chicks and using an incubator to raise them, you will still need to rehome the roosters that will account for about half of your new chicks. The shelters are already overrun with roosters and often cannot keep more than a few at a time.

Want to check out a company that breeds layer hens? Click here.

Debeaking is Painful

For the female chickens the suffering is just getting started when they arrive at their new home, where they will live the next 1.5-2years of their life. In battery cages chickens are crammed together, so that they cannot even stretch their wings. The conditions of battery farms have been widely documented. Due to these cramped conditions the hens may

debeaking chicken Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

Debeaking is very painful for the chicks.

become aggressive and peck at each other. This is why debeaking is a universal practice amongst commercial poultry farmers.

The code of practice allows up to half of the upper beak to be removed and a third of the lower beak to be removed. Hot blades are used to remove part of the beak with no anesthetic. At first people believed that there was no feeling in a hen’s beak. However now we know better. This quote is from Wikipedia about chickens’ beaks:

The beak contains nociceptors that sense pain and noxious stimuli. Beak trimming excites nociceptors. Following a trim, the nociceptors in the beak stump show abnormal patterns of neural discharge, which has been interpreted as acute pain.

So basically is hurts like hell! Despite this knowledge debeaking is still common practice and it does not just happen on battery farms. Free range hens are not in cages, but they are often still very crowded together, which can result in cannibalism. Therefore debeaking is allowed and very commonly used on free range farms. Even eggs labeled as humane allow for debeaking. Naturally hens are not cannibals, but even free range farmers do not allow a natural life for their hens – far from it.

Forced Molting – Starving Hens

Another practice that is common for both battery and free range hens is that of Forced Molting. Naturally chickens would molt in the Autumn and during this time they would produce less eggs. The purpose of natural molting is so that the hens will have full, fresh feathers by winter. After her molt the hen’s reproductive system will have recovered somewhat and she will start laying eggs again, although usually 10-30% less than in their first year.

In factory farms and sometimes free range farms too, the hens are given artificial lighting, feed and a very unnatural environment. They also lay a large amount of eggs (due to

forced molting Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

Hens being starved into forced molting

breeding, diet and lighting). This means that they will eventually produce less eggs. In this situation the birds are either sent to slaughter and a new flock brought in, or the company may use forced molting, so that after forced molting the birds will start to lay eggs again.

To induce molting a farmer has to subject the hens to stress. This can be done at any time of the year and as you can imagine is incredibly inhumane. The most common method of inducing molting is to starve the chickens. A farmer may withhold all food for a period of 2 weeks. Some farmers may also follow this with a short withdrawal from water as well. Can you imagine how awful this must be for the hens? Some hens will starve to death in this period. In fact starving hens in this way has been proved to be so cruel that it has been banned in the UK and EU. In those countries farmers can still induce molting by causing stress in other ways.

Cramped Conditions

Although free range hens are not kept in cages and there may be a few more humane farms out there that let them wander in fields, most commonly hens are still kept in cramped conditions. Thousands of hens are packed into sheds and although they must have access to the outdoors, there are no regulations on the size of the outdoor space. This means that thousands of hens could be sharing a tiny outdoor space, with the majority of them cramped indoors unable to express their natural behaviors.

free range chicken farm 300x208 Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

A 'free range' farm

Just like battery farmers, free range farmers are in it for the money. This means that when chickens break bones or become ill they will more than likely be left to die. Veterinary treatment is far too expensive and the farmers have so many chickens it would be very hard to monitor the health of all of them.

I agree that free range eggs are a better choice than battery eggs, but the lives these chickens live is hardly natural or humane.

Slaughter

The day will come when the chickens get out of the farm. Sadly this day is when they are going to the slaughter house. All farms will slaughter the hens when they are between 1-2 years of age. These hens are known as ‘spent hens’. This is because their egg production will have slowed down significantly. After this new, young hens will come in to take their place. Naturally a hen could live to 9-11 years.

Slaughter for ex-layers is as disgusting and inhumane as the slaughter of broiler chickens. The animals are often not effectively stunned before killing and will die a painful death. Although their meat is not high quality they will enter the food chain as soup, pies, chicken stock or animal food.

chicken slaughter 300x196 Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)

Stressed chickens just before slaughter

In 2003 a public outcry brought attention to a California ranch that was reported to have discarded thousands of live hens using a wood chipper; no charges were brought because, as

it turned out, this is a common industry practice.

Hens are slaughtered at this age whether on battery farms or free range. Either way by buying eggs you are contributing to slaughter.

Go Vegan!

Cutting eggs out of your diet is surprisingly easy. These days there are excellent egg replacements you can use to bake cakes etc. If you are not much of a cook you can buy plenty of delicious vegan meals, cakes and other goodies ready made.

go vegan hug a chicken 225x300 Why You Should Stop Eating Eggs (Yes Even Free Range)By going vegan you are helping to make a difference. Not only will you not be contributing to the cruelty, but your diet choices may help influence others and make people think about their food choices.

For a free vegan starter pack click here.

As part of our mission here at StartanAnimalSanctuary.com we want to inform the public on the truth about egg production. We also hope to rescue some ‘spent hens’ that would otherwise be headed to slaughter and show people that chickens are beautiful animals that deserve compassion and love.

Incoming search terms for the article:

  • Share/Bookmark

Similar Animal Sanctuary Stuff:

  1. A Conversation with a Battery Egg Farmer In the UK there are various schemes to rehome at...
  2. Ex-Battery Hen Fund Raiser – Can You Help Us Help Them? Imagine being a battery hen. You have been trapped in...
  3. Battery Hens Saved from Slaughter! It has been a busy few weeks here at StartanAnimalSanctuary.com....
  4. NSW Hen Rescue Site Launched It has been a busy couple of weeks as we...
  5. 6 Rescued Battery Hens On Friday me and my friend Sharron rescued 6 battery...

Comments (6)

I appreciate the awareness you are creating and your concern for animal life. It is commendable. It is possible, however, to consume eggs humanely. For example, if your family needs 4 laying hens to supply their eggs, you can, as you previously mentioned, hatch your own fertilized eggs. It is not that hard to rehome some roosters. It may take a little time to find a good home, but it is not impossible.

Hi TJ,

Thank you for your comment. I would have to disagree with you that it is not that hard to rehome roosters. During my short time working at the RSPCA several roosters were put down due to lack of space. I am currently trying to help someone rehome their 2 roosters with not much luck. It is very hard as shelters are overrun and already have too many roosters and people in suburbia are not allowed to keep them.

ledgestration needs to be brought in to protect these poor birds.I have rescued 6 ex battery hens,even after 2 months they still look abit tatty.But the joy they have brought to my family and me when I go in the back yard and shout them they come running like little dogs.They come and look over my shoulder if im doing anything.I now cant imagine my mornings without them.I would love to rehome more exbats but my rehoming site is in York and I live in Sheffield.Not far some my say but I would like to give a bigger donation but have to spend most of the money on petrol.Keep up the good work.x Irene

I question just how much you really know about raising chickens at home. The best way to get started is to buy a few young hens and a rooster from another farmer and after that, the hen sits on the eggs until they hatch and then she raises the chicks. Believe me, leaving the raising of chicks to the hens is a lot less time-consuming than trying to do it yourself. Also, people who raise their own chickens do not need to re-home the roosters, they kill and eat them.

Hello 2lacy,

I question whether you have even read this artice. We are not trying to find the cheapest/quickest way to raise chickens, we are looking at the cruelty involved in egg production. I also point out that whilst raising chickens of your own may be more humane than other options you still have to consider the roosters that will be born. Killing them is not an option for anyone who has an ounce of compassion for animals and the shelters are overrun. That is why going vegan is the only humane option.

Hello Irene,

Thank you for your comment. I agree hens are full of personality and curiosity. I love how they follow people around and express such joy in everything they do such as taking a dust bath or basking in the sun.

It makes it even more horrific that the poor girls are unable to express any natural behavior in the cages. It is wonderful to hear that your hens have brought you so much joy and I am sure they feel the same way about you.

Write a comment

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes

Powered by Yahoo! Answers